The
Persuaders! - Volume 4
Region 2 UK, Western Europe, Japan, South Africa TEST DISC REVIEWED Macrovision
copy protected
|
![]() |
This review is the property by Drummond Grieve. Unauthorised duplication in whole or in part is prohibited. All opinions expressed herein are mine and are not endorsed by Carlton or The Morning After. The following review is based around a Carlton test disc which may or may not bear any resemblance to the production version which will be available in shops.
All of the images on this page (with the exception of the DVD sleeve) were taken directly off the disc via a DVD-ROM drive, cropped, resized and compressed as jpg's. Clicking an image will take you to a larger version.
EPISODES:
THE
PICTURE
as with volume 3, all episodes on this disc have been re-mastered by Jonathan Wood and his team at the BBC (one of the plusses of outsourcing). The pictures are nothing short of amazing. The colour palette is rich; contrast is perfect and detail is... er... detailed. Definition? whoa! For the most part the picture is razor sharp exhibiting a level of visual detail never seen in the home environment. I literally watched each of the four episodes so impressive was the colourful clarity of the transfers. The only shots which didn't come up well were 'process' shots, or opticals (overlaps in dissolves, shots with titles et al), and location focus cock-ups (of which there are a couple which hithertofore went unnoticed in the general fuzz of a vhs picture). The quality of the supplementals is variable as is usually the case with old and neglected source material. But rest assured the effort made at the grading stage is plain to see with each separate element looking as good as decent transfer gear can deliver. Negative aspects? Well, there's always going to be DVD equivalents of the kids who spoil it for everyone else in the class. It has to be pointed out that in the test disc there were a couple of instances of encoding errors - minor as it happens but present nonetheless. The most eye-catching instance occurred at the 37m 08s mark of The Long Goodbye and lasted for about 6 frames or so. I haven't a clue what the correct technical term is so I'll just include a picture (28kb). Main title fade-outs seem to have presented problems at the authoring stage with a few artefacts of this variety towards the 'black' end of the fade on some of the episodes. While it hardly ruins the viewing experience it still catches the eye and it would be remiss not to mention it. The opening shot from The Old, the New and the Deadly suffers from noticeable compression artefacting inasmuch as the flat (day for) night sky looks like it's crawling. Again this does not mar the overall experience but as it is the first shot of the first episode it stands out like the proverbial dog's bollocks. It was interesting to note that the bitrate of volume 4 is 8mbps (megabits per second) whereas it's predecessor was encoded at 9mbps. Naturally enough the higher the bitrate the less likelihood of compression artefacting (although this in itself is no guarantee of flawless picture). Considering what is contained on the disc, I am surprised the lower bitrate was the preferred option but not being an authoring guru I'm unaware of the practicalities of bitrate choice. The emphatic final judgement regards picture quality however is 99.99% approval. The visuals of volume 4 are detailed, colourful and unarguably an uncommon pleasure to watch. The glitches referred to are virtually insignificant and may be rectified for the production run of discs. THE
SOUND
The audio of The Persuaders! can only be judged relative to its production parameters i.e. a monaural soundtrack produced for monaural transmission accessed via frequency-limited tv speakers, serviceable but never exciting. While the audio has been tweaked & equalised to sound better than ever, it is entirely unfair to expect sonics that even begin to approach the least active of modern soundtracks. Nothing short of the discovery of the separate magnetic tracks used to make the soundtrack composite is going to change the fact. But it has to be said that the 4 included episodes feature a much better audio response than any transmission or domestic video format has delivered to date. The audio of the items in the supplement section is variable and once again the age and condition of the source elements must be taken into account. Volume levels vary between supplementary items. This is deliberate and relies on the ability of the viewer to grasp and exercise the principles of audio attenuation whose practical outcome is turning the sound up and/or down via the remote control - a challenge to be sure. THE
EXTRA'S
"Can it last?" I hear you cry. Well, with only another 3 discs to go until all 24 episodes are available on dvd, Carlton product manager, Jaz Wiseman, assures us yes it can as there are still a number of rare and extremely interesting items sitting in boxes in the ITC vaults which can be easily secreted in the folds and pockets of Mr Carlton's raincoat. TRAILER
A point of interest re: the trailer is there is only 1 surviving 35mm print from which a video master could be struck. Under this circumstance we are very lucky indeed that the trailer was in a decent state of repair. Film-based dirt aside, the transfer is excellent. The trailer itself is "as boring as bat shit" (a common term 'round my way) but not even Mr Carlton can be blamed for that. BUMPERS
There are two bumpers included on the disc - a standard one for your common or garden commercial break and a "sponsor" one complete with voice-over:, "The Persuaders! ...brought to you by...". This sponsor type bumper was common in US tv broadcasts and as the voice is an American one, I presume the bumper was made for that market. In any event the majority of fans will likely be seeing the bumpers for the very first time or at least believe they are seeing them for the first time (I saw the first broadcast on Scottish TV and my normally photographic mind had no recollection whatsoever of the bumper). It should be pointed out that we are quite fortunate to have bumper 1 with sound. Only the image exists in the ITC archives (the audio was sep-mag - separate magnetic - and had long since gone the way of the world). Jaz Wiseman to the rescue: "The audio was taken from my 1982 VHS copy of Greensleeves (the only place I know that it exists...). We edited the sound in a sound [computer software] package to get the best quality possible and then synched it to the vision master using the VHS copy of Greensleeves to get the audio cues right..."This is not the first time the assistance of fans has allowed the repair of programmes or items. The BBC's Doctor Who restoration team have been able to utilise domestic audio recordings held by fans to re-construct damaged or missing audio from a few early serials. It's not the ideal of course but then beggars can't be slaggers. Due to the incompatibility of the resultant sound file with the native DVD audio format, the audio of bumper 1 comes out of the left channel only. I am reliably informed that for reasons only a technical boffin could explain, this was the only satisfactory option of presenting the audio. STILL
& MEMORABILIA GALLERY
As per usual the production stills are generally relevant to episodes which appear on the disc - which illustrates that some effort has gone into the selection of the images. Each picture is accompanied by an explanatory blurb which includes names of featured personnel. The gallery is presented in a slide show format so one only needs to select the gallery, sit back and let the show unfold. Images are sourced from both the ITC vaults and Jaz Wiseman's private collection. This is the case with the second gallery whose subject is international releases of the Persuaders! theme (album, single or CD). It's a great opportunity to show the international appeal and impact of John Barry's theme. All the images are sourced from Jaz Wiseman's private collection. "ITC
PRESENTS" COLOUR IDENT
Not enough can be said about these seemingly small touches; they give the impression that some, dare I say it, love for the program has gone into the presentation of the disc - something which is nearly always lacking in videos or dvd's. MENU'S
& DISC NAVIGATION
THE
SUMMARY
Volume 4 of The Persuaders! is the best disc to date and, if nothing else, shows that Mr Carlton does listen to the consumer. None of the aural or visual authoring glitches that marred previous volumes are evident on this one. Fifteen quid well spent! If they can keep to this minimum standard then the remaining discs will be risk-free purchases. Well done to all concerned. |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
RATINGS
(1 star poor rating - 5
star excellent)
ratings are relative to
the age and quality
of the original elements
PICTURE
|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
GLITCHES
|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
SOUND
|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
EXTRA'S
|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
VALUE
|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |